Learn about customised holidays, what they can include, and how a travel agent can help tailor your journey around your interests, budget and travel style.
Travel
Group tours vs independent travel: which is better?
Not sure whether to join a group tour or travel independently? Compare the pros and cons of each travel style before your next holiday.
Planning a holiday involves more than choosing where to go. How you travel can have a significant impact on your experience, budget and enjoyment.
Some travellers prefer the convenience of an organised group tour, while others enjoy the freedom of exploring independently. Both options have advantages, depending on your destination, travel experience and personal preferences.
Whether you're planning a European adventure, exploring Japan or discovering Australia, understanding the differences between group tours and independent travel can help you choose the right holiday.
RACV Travel & Experiences can help you find an option that suits your interests, budget and travel style. RACV Members also get 15 per cent off RACV Travel Insurance.*
More: Are travel agents worth it? 10 reasons to book with a travel expert
What's the difference between a guided tour and independent travel?
The main difference between guided tours vs independent travel is how much of your holiday is organised in advance.
Group tours typically follow a planned itinerary, with accommodation, transport, activities and some meals included. A tour leader or local guide may accompany the group, providing destination knowledge and managing logistics.
Independent travel involves organising your own itinerary, including flights, accommodation, transport and activities. It offers greater flexibility but requires more research and planning.
Both travel styles can suit different budgets, destinations and interests.
When is a group tour a better choice?
Group tours are ideal for travellers who prefer convenience, structure and expert guidance. Benefits of group tours include:
- Less planning - transport, accommodation and sightseeing are often organised.
- Local expertise - knowledgeable guides provide insights into destinations, history and culture.
- Social opportunities - meet like-minded travellers and share experiences.
- Convenience - visit multiple destinations without managing every booking or transfer.
Group tours can be particularly appealing when visiting unfamiliar destinations or travelling through several countries. For example, a guided tour through Europe or Japan can simplify transport arrangements, language barriers and sightseeing logistics.
More: How to choose and plan the perfect family trip
When is independent travel a better choice?
Independent travel suits travellers who value flexibility, spontaneity and exploring at their own pace. Benefits of independent travel include:
- Greater freedom - choose where to go, what to see and how long to stay.
- Personalised experiences - build an itinerary around your interests.
- Flexible spending - select accommodation, transport and activities to suit your budget.
- Spontaneity - change plans or discover unexpected attractions along the way.
Independent travel can work particularly well in destinations with accessible public transport, established tourism infrastructure and minimal language barriers. However, organising everything yourself can require considerable time and research.
Group tours are ideal for travellers who prefer convenience, structure and guidance. Image: Getty
Which option is better for first-time travellers?
For first-time international travellers, a group tour can provide reassurance and convenience.
Having transport, accommodation and activities arranged reduces the pressure of navigating unfamiliar destinations. Experienced guides can also help travellers understand local customs and overcome language barriers.
Independent travel can still be suitable for beginners, particularly when visiting destinations with straightforward transport connections and familiar languages.
Ultimately, confidence, destination and personal preferences matter more than previous travel experience.
More: How to pack light for trips with strict luggage limits
How do costs compare between group tours and independent travel?
When comparing a package tour or independent travel, the cheapest option isn't always obvious.
Group tours often bundle accommodation, transport, sightseeing and selected meals into one price. This can provide greater cost certainty and sometimes offer savings through group arrangements.
Independent travel allows greater control over spending, including choosing budget accommodation, cheaper transport and free attractions. However, additional expenses such as transfers, entrance fees and activities can quickly add up.
Compare the total holiday cost rather than the upfront price, including what's covered and any optional extras.
More: 8 reasons why you should consider travel insurance
Which travel style offers a more authentic local experience?
Both group tours and independent travel can provide meaningful cultural experiences.
Guided tours often include local experts, cultural activities and visits to attractions that travellers might otherwise overlook.
Independent travel offers opportunities to explore neighbourhoods, discover local restaurants and interact with residents at your own pace.
Neither approach automatically guarantees a more authentic experience. The quality of local interactions, itinerary and activities matters most.
More: Best food travel destinations and food tours around the world
Independent travel suits travellers who value flexibility and spontaneity. Image: Getty
Can you combine group tours and independent travel in the same trip?
Yes. Combining guided tours and independent travel can offer the best of both worlds.
For example, you could join a guided tour through several European countries before spending additional days exploring Paris or Rome independently. Alternatively, book a short guided experience within a longer self-planned holiday.
This approach provides structured sightseeing alongside opportunities for personal exploration.
More: Best European river cruises for your next Europe holiday
How do you decide which travel style is right for you?
When weighing up a group tour vs independent travel, consider your budget, destination, confidence and preferred pace.
Ask yourself whether you enjoy organising travel arrangements, prefer flexibility or value the convenience of having an itinerary planned. You should also consider how much time you have, whether you're travelling alone and which experiences matter most.
RACV Travel & Experiences can help you explore both options, offering expert advice, tailored recommendations and assistance with holiday planning and bookings.
*RACV Travel Insurance Member discount applies to the premium only (not applicable taxes).
Royal Automobile Club of Victoria (RACV) Limited (ABN 44 004 060 833, AR No. 1243563) (RACV) is an authorised representative of the RACV Travel Insurance insurer Tokio Marine & Nichido Fire Insurance Co., Ltd. (ABN 80 000 438 291 AFSL 246 548) (Tokio Marine). Tokio Marine Management (Australasia) Pty Ltd (ABN 69 001 488 455, AR No. 1313066) is an authorised representative of Tokio Marine, and administers RACV Travel Insurance as the managing agent on behalf of Tokio Marine.
Terms, conditions (including eligibility criteria), exclusions, limits and sub-limits apply. Any advice is general advice only, and does not take into account your specific objectives, financial situation or needs. Before you purchase, please consider the Combined Product Disclosure Statement (PDS) / Financial Services Guide (FSG) and Target Market Determinations (TMDs) available on RACV’s website, or on request from RACV.