Best 4x4 Dual Cab Ute

Australia's Best Cars 2018

Best 4x4 Dual Cab Ute

The popularity of dual cab utes goes from strength to strength as these workhorses cross over into family car territory.

Winner: Ford Ranger XLT 3.2


Currently Ford’s most popular model and one of the best sellers in this class, the Ranger has dominated Australia’s Best Cars 4x4 dual cab ute category since its inclusion in the program in 2013. It has lost its crown only once when it fell to the eighth-generation Toyota HiLux in 2015.

With some updates since then, the Ranger has once again asserted itself, and was looking promising for a win in 2018 even before the Blue Oval offered a new five years/unlimited-kilometre warranty for new vehicles delivered from 1 May.

The Ranger XLT and HiLux SR5 are the two dearest utes in our scoresheets. But the Ford’s depreciation, running and repair costs and insurance premiums hover around the class averages. Standard equipment levels are good, and only the Holden Colorado LTZ offers more kit for slightly less money.

The XLT’s standard fit-out has a full suite of airbags and includes full-length side curtain airbags, a rear-view camera, park sensors front and rear, a rear diff-lock, dual-zone climate control, rain-sensing wipers, side steps, sports bar, DAB+ radio, navigation, and tyre-pressure monitoring. Also fitted is Ford’s latest-gen SYNC 3 entertainment and communications system with voice recognition and an 8.0-inch colour touchscreen with ‘pinch and swipe’ capability.

Towing ability and practical design are important in a ute, and the Ranger isn’t found wanting. The XLT comes with a towbar and trailer sway control as standard, and it’s rated to a best-in-class 3500-kilogram maximum towing mass. A generously proportioned tray with standard tub-liner, six load restraint mounting points, a power outlet, load area illumination and a payload to deal with work or play all rated well with our judges. Like the HiLux, the Ford has a 230-volt inverter power outlet in the cabin.

Comfortable seating in all positions and cabin space that’s equal best in class help the Ranger’s cause too. Inside and out, the Ranger rates highly for its build and finish quality, with a premium look that shows how far utes have progressed in recent years from their relatively spartan workhorse predecessors.

Performance from the Ranger’s 147kW, 3.2-litre, five-cylinder turbo-diesel again impressed the judges, whether on-road or lugging its way through the bush. With a gutsy 470Nm delivered between 1750 and 2500rpm, it easily shrugged off the challenges of our off-road test loop, including hauling a 500-kilogram payload and four burly ABC judges up a steep, muddy and badly rutted track. Off-road, the Ranger proved as accomplished and capable as the best the class can offer.

The big Ford’s road manners are far more car-like and sophisticated than might be expected in a vehicle built primarily to work for a living and tackle tough off-road terrain. Steering, handling and ride are as good as it gets in the class.

The popularity of dual cab utes goes from strength to strength with Australian buyers. The Ford Ranger XLT exemplifies the versatility, driveability and relative civility that the modern dual cab ute can deliver. That’s why it has again stamped its authority over a class it has virtually made its own. And you can expect the Ranger to be a force to be reckoned with in the future, too, with Ford announcing powerful new engines providing up to 500Nm, a 10-speed auto, advanced driver-assistance features, and other improvements for 2019.

Second place: VW Amarok TDI420 Core


The VW Amarok has finished at the pointy end of Australia’s Best Cars’ dual cab 4x4 class in years past and, once again, has provided a worthy challenge to the highly successful Ford Ranger.

The Amarok’s opening gambit looks solid enough, with most value-for-money scores giving the Toyota and HiLux something to contend with. In TDI420 Core specification, it has a significant price advantage that also flows through to lower depreciation losses. Ongoing costs, such as running and repair, insurance and fuel are marginally better too. But it falls short of the Ford’s better warranty and dealer spread, and its lower purchase price reflects a less generous standard features list.

The Amarok’s cargo tray is the largest in the pack, handily able to carry a standard Aussie pallet between the wheel arches. There’s also a tailgate load-rated to 200 kilograms, and cargo area light. Maximum rated towing at 3000 kilograms trails both the HiLux and Ranger.

The Amarok’s bi-turbo diesel is mated to an eight-speed auto and delivers surprising performance, but doesn’t quite match the grunt of its rivals’ larger displacement engines. The ute is capable off-road, but we found it more likely to have clearance issues over moguls and heavily rutted terrain.

It remains one of the more civilised and car-like offerings in this category.

Third place: Toyota HiLux SR5


With the VW Amarok once again in the mix alongside Ford Ranger, the HiLux SR5 – a class winner in 2015 – has been relegated to the third step of the podium.

In value for money, the HiLux generally trades blows pretty evenly with the Ford. However, the Toyota’s warranty falls well behind Ford’s newly announced five years/unlimited-kilometre coverage.

Our judges found cabin space in the rear not quite as generous as the Ranger, but they liked the recent inclusion of rear-console air vents, something missing from the Ford. Improving its ergonomic credentials are B-pillar grab handles for rear passengers, push-button start and proximity entry, and steering tilt and reach adjustment (tilt only is the norm on most in the class).

The 2.8-litre turbo-diesel offers a respectable level of performance on and off-road, and feels a little more refined than the Ford while doing it. As the numbers show, the HiLux is a capable vehicle in off-road terrain and easily handled our steep and muddy off-road test section, both unladen and with 500 kilograms in the tray and four occupants on board.

With a maximum towing capacity of 3200 kilograms when equipped with an auto transmission, the HiLux falls shy of the Ford’s 3500-kilogram rating. But the ever-popular HiLux SR5 has much to recommend it and remains a great example of the 4WD dual cab genre.

Best 4x4 Dual Cab Ute

Best 4x4 Dual Cab Ute

WEIGHTING

Ford Ranger XLT 3.2

VW Amarok TDI420 Core

Toyota HiLux SR5

Details

Scores are weighted – critical, high, medium or low – according to their importance to buyers of cars in this class. The overall average totals reflect these weightings.

Type: Dual cab ute
Fuel type: Diesel
Fuel economy: 8.7L/100km
Engine size: 3.2L, 5cyl
Transmission: 6-spd auto
Ind. drive-away: $60,488
ANCAP: 5 stars

Type: Dual cab ute
Fuel type: 
Diesel
Fuel economy: 
8.3L/100km
Engine size: 
2.0L, 4cyl
Transmission: 
8-spd auto
Ind. drive-away:
 $51,690
ANCAP:
N/A

Type: Dual cab ute
Fuel type: Diesel
Fuel economy: 8.5L/100km
Engine size: 2.8L, 4cyl
Transmission: 6-spd auto
Ind. drive-away: $61,194
ANCAP: 5 stars

VALUE FOR MONEY
Pricing

Medium

3

7

3

Cost of depreciation ($)

Medium

5

6

3

Running and repair costs

Medium

6

8

5

Fuel consumption

High

3

4

3

Warranty and dealer access

Medium

8

3

4

Insurance

Low

5

8

2

Standard features

High

7

4

7

DESIGN AND FUNCTION
Safety

Critical

7

6

7

Environment

Critical

4

4

4

Seating comfort

High

7

8

7

Space - cabin

High

7

7

6

Space - tray

High

8

9

8

Practicality

High

8

8

8

Ergonomics

High

8

8

9

Build and finish quality

Medium

8

8

8

ON THE ROAD
Rated towing

Critical

9

7

7

Payload

Medium

6

7

6

Performance

High

8

7

7

Ride

Medium

8

8

7

Handling

High

8

8

8

Braking

High

7

7

7

Smoothness and quietness

Medium

7

8

8

OFF-ROAD
Engine, gearing and traction

High

8

8

8

Clearances and articulation

High

7

6

7

OVERALL AVERAGE

1102

1078

1040

RACV Car Loans are quick and easy to apply for and if you're not happy within 21-days, you can cancel your loan with our Best Deal Guarantee