Honda v Toyota

RACV RoyalAuto Magazine

Honda CRV Vti-s

Ignore the passion and emotion of motoring when looking at either of these SUVs – they’re all about the simple efficiency of travelling.

Snapshot

Honda CR-V VTI-S

Price: $35,290 + orc.
Engine: 2.4L 4cyl petrol auto
Safety: ESC, ABS, 6 airbags, reversing camera, blind spot system, 5-star ANCAP.
Economy: 9.4L/100km.
RACV rating: * * *

Toyota RAV4 GXL

Toyota RAV4 GXL

Price: $36,990 + orc.
Engine: 2.5L 4cyl petrol auto.
Safety: ESC, ABS, 7 airbags, reversing camera, 5-star ANCAP.
Economy: 9.7L/100km.
RACV rating: * * * 1/2

After small cars, medium SUVs are where the bulk of buyers are heading and principally for one reason: they’re easy to live with. This segment is well stocked with reputable brands, and among the top handful are, of course, Toyota and Honda. Step in and out of a modern SUV countless times a day and you start to forget about things such as driving pleasure, because it’s all about comfort, familiarity, packaging and the simple efficiency of travel. We review and compare the Toyota RAV4 and Honda CR-V.

Reliable and practical

Toyota RAV4 and Honda CR-V are longstanding, well-respected models within their respective brands and have been recently upgraded. Both have enviable reputations for reliability and they deliver the essential practicality sought by young families and retirees alike.

Each range starts with a budget two-wheel-drive, 2.0-litre petrol manual model for under $28,000 (plus on-road costs). But more popular are automatic all-wheel-drive petrol variants, namely Honda’s 2.4-litre VTi-S and Toyota’s 2.5-litre GXL – our test cars – which add the potential for doing more than simply dispensing the daily grind, e.g. touring adventures. As well as higher-grade all-wheel-drive petrol variants, both RAV4 and CR-V have turbo-diesel models in their line-ups.

Honda launched a refreshed CR-V last November, including a new display/audio touch-screen and new alloys. In January, Toyota’s RAV4 adopted bolder exterior styling and a redesigned cabin. The chassis was revised for sharper dynamics and a more insulated, quieter ride.

Five-star safety

Our review cars both have a five-star ANCAP safety rating, RAV4 having a driver knee airbag, while CR-V has a standard left-turn blind-spot camera and front parking sensors. Advanced safety items, including autonomous emergency braking, lane departure assist, radar cruise control and cross-traffic alert, are a $2500 option on all RAV4s but only available on the top-spec CR-V for $3500.

These mid-size SUVs are notable for easy access, good cabin space and everyday practicality. Interior measurements are remarkably similar; the fundamental difference is presentation and finish. CR-V has more back-seat width, while RAV4 has marginally more head and leg room up front, rake-adjustable rear seats and better load versatility because CR-V’s tip/fold back seat restricts the ultimate load length.

Obvious difference

Our review shows the most obvious difference is RAV4’s more modern cabin. Despite its slightly confronting dark, square dash, the presentation is fresher and the usability more logical, more so the longer you live with it. By comparison CR-V is brighter with a more open feel but it’s plastic, has flimsy controls and the design has been around for a while.

Honda’s seating is also somewhat ordinary when compared with the Toyota’s shaping and long-term support. For child seats, RAV4 places top tether points on the seat back, while CR-V has them in the roof, although this did not appear restrictive. Also of note is the Honda carries a full-size alloy spare wheel, because curiously RAV4 has a space-saver despite having more off-road features in its driveline, including a differential lock and hill descent control. CR-V’s on-demand all-wheel-drive set-up is a balance between traction in sloppy conditions and better fuel economy.

Good performance overall

Overall performance from both vehicles is good, with little perceivable difference between Toyota’s six-speed CVT and Honda’s conventional five-speed automatic. CR-V is arguably a little more agile with a lighter steering feel around city streets and carparks. While it glides easily on the open road, it also feels lighter, with a tendency to jiggle over poor surfaces and on dirt. The slightly heavier RAV4 feels more substantial, with a stiffer body structure, and its suspension is generally more settled on rough roads. Fuel economy always favoured CR-V, particularly on the open road, but in general use the margin is less distinct and neither car is that great overall.

The verdict

Mid-size SUVs are an innocuous tool of life, judged by how well they disguise and cope with the tedium of the daily routine. With that in mind, the conservative Honda CR-V is best suited to suburbia while the more modern Toyota RAV4 is superior on regional roads and farm tracks.

TOYOTA RAV 4 GXL

Price: $36,990 + $3953 (est.) orc. Metallic paint $550. Model range $32,990-$44,490.
Safety: ESC. ABS. 7 airbags. Reversing camera. Rear parking sensors. Auto lights/wipers. ISOFIX fittings.
Connectivity: Toyota Link phone app. Bluetooth. Single CD/MP3 audio.
Vehicle features: Dual-zone climate-control. LED headlights. Fog lights. Cloth upholstery. Proximity key. Central locking.
Driver features: Cruise control. Hill start assist. Hill descent control. Tilt/reach-adjustable steering wheel.
Options: Safety pack $2500.
Specifications: Drivetrain: 2494cc 4cyl petrol engine. 132kW@6000rpm, 233Nm@4100rpm. 6spd CVT. AWD. 91-RON petrol. 60L tank. 9.7L/100km (RACV test figure); 8.5L/100km (govt figure).
Wheels: 18” alloy, 235/55 R18 tyres. Space-saver spare wheel.
Towing: 1500kg braked trailer capacity (150kg towball load).
Environment: 198g/km CO2.
Service/repairs: 6-month/10,000km capped-price services for 3 years. 3-year/100,000km warranty.

HONDA CR-V VTi-S

Price: $35,290 + $3594 (est.) orc. Metallic paint $575. Model range $33,990-$49,820.
Safety: ESC. ABS. 6 airbags. Reversing camera. Front/rear parking sensors. Blind spot information. Auto lights/wipers. ISOFIX fittings.
Connectivity: Phone cable. Bluetooth. Single CD/MP3 audio.
Vehicle features: Dual-zone climate-control. Fog lights. Daytime running lights. Cloth upholstery. Central locking. Roof rails. Alarm.
Driver features: Cruise control. Hill start assist. Tilt/reach-adjustable steering wheel. Steering wheel paddles. Keyless start.
Specifications: Drivetrain: 2354cc 4cyl petrol engine. 140kW@7000rpm, 222Nm@4400rpm. 5spd auto. AWD. 91-RON petrol. 58L tank. 9.4L/100km (RACV test figure); 8.7L/100km (govt figure).
Wheels: 17” alloy, 225/65 R17 tyres. Full-size alloy spare wheel.
Towing: 1500kg braked trailer capacity (100kg towball load).
Environment: 201g/km CO2.
Service/repairs: 6-month/10,000km capped-price services for 5 years. 3-year/100,000km warranty.

titleimage
Things to look for when buying an SUV
titleimage

RACV can help

Find it. RACV’s online car-buying service
Finance it. RACV Car Loans
Insure it. RACV Insurance
Package it. EPAC
 

The rest of the best

MAZDA CX-5 MAXX SPORT. High build quality and great value for money are its hallmarks. $35,790 (2.5L petrol)

SUBARU FORESTER 2.5i-S. This AWD pioneer has more off-road ability than most. $39,490 (2.5L petrol)

HYUNDAI TUCSON ELITE. Well equipped, solid and dependable. A good all-rounder. $38,240 (1.6L petrol)

Mazda CX-5 Maxx Sport
Subary Forester 2.5i-S
Hyhundai Tucson Elite
Written by Ernest Litera
August 01, 2016